Money From Facebook’s Zuckerberg Used to Undermine Election, Violate Law: Report
December 16, 2020
Hundreds of millions of dollars from Facebook founder Mark Zuckerberg was used to violate election laws, according to a new report.
tỷ phú trẻ Zuckerberg,sáng lập Facebook và cô vợ Tàu
The Amistad Project of the Thomas More Society, a national constitutional litigation organization, released the 39-page report, alleging that Zuckerberg’s $500 million given to election officials was used to treat voters unequally and improperly influence the election for Democratic presidential candidate Joe Biden.
The bulk of the funds went to the Center for Tech and Civic Life (CTCL), a nonprofit started by former managers and staff at the New Organizing Institute, a progressive nonprofit.
According to the report, the nonprofit earlier this year “began sending agents into states to recruit certain Democrat strongholds to prepare grants requesting monies from” it.
For example, the center gave $100,000 to Cory Mason, the mayor of Racine, Wisconsin, to recruit four other cities to develop a plan and request a larger grant from it. Those five cities submitted such a plan in June and received $6.3 million to implement it.
That kind of privatization of elections “undermines the Help America Vote Act (HAVA), which requires state election plans to be submitted to federal officials and approved and requires respect for equal protection by making all resources available equally to all voters,” the report states.
“The provision of Zuckerberg-CTCL funds allowed these Democrat strongholds to spend roughly $47 per voter, compared to $4 to $7 per voter in traditionally Republican areas of the state. Moreover, this recruiting of targeted jurisdictions for specific government action and funding runs contrary to legislative election plans and invites government to play favorites in the election process.”
Phill Kline, director of the Thomas More Foundation’s Amistad Project, in a file photograph. (Courtesy of Phill Kline)
Mason’s spokesperson didn’t respond to a request for comment, nor did a Facebook spokesperson nor CTCL’s media office.
“This effectively is a shadow government running our elections,” Phill Kline, director of the Amistad Project, said at a press conference in Virginia.
“Government has the core responsibility of managing elections. We don’t put out elections for bid. We don’t have elections brought to you by Coca Cola. It is government’s job to manage elections, and it must do so without a thumb on the scale,” he added.
The project said the main foundations funding the efforts include The Democracy Fund, New Venture Fund, Skoll Foundation, and Knight Foundation
Other nonprofits deemed key to distributing the money besides CTCL were named as the Center for Electronic Innovation Research, the Center for Civic Design, the National Vote at Home Institute, the Center for Secure and Modern Elections, and Rock the Vote.
None immediately responded to requests for comment.
lãnh tu phe Cộng Hoà McConnell tại Thượng Viện Mỹ và vợ Tàu Elaine Chao
RSS PUBLISHED TO
McConnell and China connection
While researching McConnell’s background, I came across information about his wife Elaine Chao that I put aside because it didn’t fit into the jigsaw puzzle of a story I was then assembling around the senate
majority leader tyrant.
I cut one piece of information — the oddness of Chao’s connection with a Californian internet startup called Multacom — specifically because of the speculative nature of the links. But that omission niggled at me; there were facts here that I felt were germane to the big picture even though I couldn’t pin them down with definite conclusions. Instead they raised more questions but that in itself can be informative so this strange little snippet from Chao’s past has been reinstated.
Then there were other connections around Elaine Chao that I just didn’t make at the time because I was focusing on McConnell with Chao in his background. Reverse their positions in the picture and the new perspective instantly adds another intriguing layer to the story.
Elaine Chao’s father, James Si-Cheng Chao, was born and raised in China. He attended the National Chiao Tung University in Shanghai where he met and befriended Jiang Zemin. That friendship was destined to have a significant effect on American politics.
After university, their paths diverged. James Chao joined the China Maritime Trust Limited shipping company as a cadet, rose in the ranks to become one of their youngest merchant marine captains, and moved to Taiwan with the company when the communists seized Shanghai in 1949.
Jiang Zemin went to Moscow to take up a traineeship with the Stalin Automobile Works before returning to China where, after a brief stint with the Changchun First Automobile Works, he was transferred to government services.
James Chao moved to New York in 1958 and, immediately after graduating with an MBA in 1964, founded the Foremost Group, a shipping, trading and finance enterprise. Back in China, Jiang Zemin was rising in prominence and rank to become a member of the Central Committee of the Communist Party.
When the two reconnected isn’t clear. We do know that James Chao placed an order for two ships to be built at the state-owned shipyard in Shanghai during Jiang’s tenure there as mayor.
From the South China Morning Post:
He started meeting Mr Jiang regularly, including three months after the Tiananmen Square crackdown in 1989, when most other American businessmen were avoiding the leadership.
GUANXI (Chinese term for political connections)
Up until this time, Chao’s eldest daughter, Elaine, had been following in her father’s footsteps with a business degree that led to an early career in banking. Her only foray into politics had been a White House Fellowship in 1983.
But soon after her father renewed his friendship with Jiang Zemin, Elaine left the banking industry and began to forge guanxi of her own in America.
Mr Chao’s daughter was rising in prominence in Republican and Asian-American circles, building a reputation as a formidable fund-raiser – a vital skill in the US political money-go-round
In 1986, she joined the Maritime Administration in the Department of Transportation and moved up to Chairwoman of the Federal Maritime Commission in 1988. A year later, the first of the Bush presidents nominated Chao to be Deputy Secretary of Transportation.
In just three years, Elaine had managed to get herself out of banking and into a position in the Executive branch of the US government. It was quite an accomplishment and it demonstrated a single-minded determination.
However it wasn’t a position that afforded her the power she needed to influence American policy on China and it soon became clear that this was part of, if not the whole point of, her political ambitions.
In 1990, Elaine Chao was introduced to Mitch McConnell, senator since 1985, divorced since 1980. Did she consider the usefulness of a congressional connection before this encounter? Or did opportunism arise from the obvious advantages to herself of cultivating the relationship? Her strong-willed character together with vaulting ambition inherited from her father suggests both are possible.
McConnell was undoubtedly an attractive proposition for her: he had a senate seat but not much money, prestige or leverage. What McConnell lacked, Elaine Chao had in abundance. Moreover, she had the capability to make him into the man he wanted to be and the partner she needed to realise her ambitions.
She introduced him to a level of society and affluence he’d never known before. She had her father, their friends and business associates throw cash by the bucket-loads into his campaign coffers. She was passionate about politics and he listened to her.
The senator had started to shift from a hawkish stance [on China that] aligned with arch-conservative Foreign Relations Committee chairman Jesse Helms to more moderate positions.
That she was the strength in their partnership was never more obvious than when she defended McConnell from a group of protesters while he cowered in the background.
They married in 1993 and traveled with James Chao to Beijing to meet up with an old family friend, Jiang Zemin, now President Jiang Zemin of the People’s Republic of China.
WINNING OVER REPUBLICANS AND INFLUENCING POLICY
In 1996, Elaine Chao became a Distinguished Fellow with The Heritage Foundation, the same year they opened an office in Hong Kong. The following year she escorted the foundation’s major donors to a handover ceremony marking the return of Hong Kong from Britain’s 99-year sovereignty to Chinese ownership.
In New Republic, senior editor John Judis credited Chao with persuading The Heritage Foundation and the GOP to change their stance on China.
Ms Chao made clear she was a proponent of ‘Greater China’ and keen to push the pro-engagement line.
Their shift toward accommodation with Beijing has happened quietly, with care to make sure connections between money and ideology are virtually impossible to trace.
Another brief controversy concerned Chao purportedly serving on the board of Multacom, a California-based company that ran internet links between the US and China in a joint venture with China Unicom. It was a minor role, a mere footnote in Elaine Chao’s bio — until 2001. Sometime in the month following her confirmation as Secretary of Labor, an earnest investigative reporter discovered that Chao had failed to list Multacom in official disclosure documents filed before taking up her role in the Bush-2 cabinet.
The lack of disclosure was described as “an inadvertent omission” but omissions of this kind were taken more seriously in 2001 than they are in the Trump administration and so it lingered for a few days until the media finally lost interest and everyone forgot about it.
Until 2017 when there was news of another incomplete disclosure form. Politico reports:
Elaine Chao’s financial disclosure form makes no mention of any previous employment with or ownership of the Foremost Group.
But in a joint father-daughter interview with the Shanghai Media Group that was recorded between Elaine Chao’s confirmation hearing and the president’s inauguration, James Chao talked about her work to build up the company.
But unlike previous administrations, the Trump administration is cool with disclosure form omissions.
Note this interview was with the Shanghai Media Group. Only once has Chao consented to do an interview with a US TV station. The occasion was her 2017 confirmation; the channel was Fox and the show was Sean Hannity’s. It should’ve been a pleasant few minutes with softball questions and lots of smiling. It’s almost was — except for one gaff, one major gaff, that unintentionally revealed what the new Secretary’s true plans were.
The following quote is taken from a March 2017 Daily Kos story which is well worth reading in full.
After saying how we needed to come up with “new and innovative ways” to revamp our country’s infrastructure, Chao said
So, basically, we allow foreign inv—uh, we allow different kinds of money, private sector money to come into the United States—I’m not saying foreign—to come and fund, let’s say a bridge or a road or it can be any kind of infrastructure.
Oh but she very definitely is saying foreign and one has to wonder how many foreign buyers she already has lined up. The Saudis are keen.
Since that appearance on Hannity, Chao has refused all other interviews with US media. Not so with Chinese requests, however. There has been more than a dozen of those, all featuring her father.
…media appearances [which] might violate a regulation that prohibits federal employees from using their public office for their “own private gain, for the endorsement of any product, service or enterprise, or for the private gain of friends, relatives, or persons with whom the employee is affiliated in a nongovernmental capacity.”
Government and legal ethics expert, Kathleen Clark, warned Chao to avoid showing any connection with the Department of Transportation on the screen. It was advice Chao totally ignored.
Not only do the DOT flags appear prominently in the New China Press interview and several other interviews, the state flag of Kentucky appears in at least one, which points up her connection to her powerful husband, Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-Ky.).
Since Chao became the Secretary of Transportation, the family shipping business has added 10 vessels to its fleet, an increase of 40%. But as the Intelligencer noted:
…it seems highly unlikely that Trump is going to punish anyone for publicly promoting their wealthy dad’s business.
It seems just as unlikely that he’d punish Chao family members for violating US sanctions on Russian businesses. They’ve been quite clever about it. While they aren’t transacting directly with sanctioned companies they are nevertheless supporting them by doing business with the China banks that entered into joint partnerships with Russian banks sanctioned by the US in 2014.
Doing business with these Chinese abettors may not be illegal but it is dishonorable, more especially because the Russians negotiated the joint partnerships in a desperate attempt to counteract the effect of the US sanctions. Providing them with any kind of relief, however indirectly, is just plain wrong.
IT ALL COMES BACK TO McCONNELL
Other controversies have swirled around Elaine Chao. Some, like her use of government planes, are hyperbolic and don’t survive serious scrutiny. Another story, filed by Politico, tries to make the case that Chao doesn’t work a full week because she often takes time off during normal working hours. But a little digging reveals she more than makes up for it by working “very late into the night, early every morning and each and every weekend“.
The real story that Politico missed is when she takes this ‘private time’:
The vast majority of Chao’s private appointments occurred on Fridays — frequently after lunchtime, and including nine Fridays when she marked at least five hours as private.
When in session, the senate week is… Monday to Thursday. The obvious conclusion: she’s spending most of that time with McConnell. Her spokesperson even said as much, listing her private activities as ranging from:
…doctor’s appointments to meeting with personal friends to tending to personal needs or regularly sharing meals with her husband.
It’s no surprise that she chooses to spend time with her husband. After all, McConnell is under a lot of stress (of his own making), keeping the government
running shut down and preventing 99 senators and 434 House members from having any say whatsoever in the people’s congress.
Elaine Chao didn’t just make McConnell into the man he wanted to be, she’s helped to create a tyrant inside the Congress. The irony is that she also made him accessible to the GOP’s billionaire donor class (deliberately), the Chinese (also deliberately) and the Russians (shit happens).
It remains to be seen if she can save McConnell from justice finally catching up with him.